Preview — $10M Catastrophic Injury Settlement | TD Law Redesign
Home / Case Results / $10M Settlement
Case Result · Catastrophic Injury

A 15-Year Fight Ended With a $10 Million Settlement

An administrative worker fell down a staircase and shattered her spine and knees. The insurance company fought her for 15 years. Thomas DeBenedetto didn't stop until she had lifetime care and one of the largest settlements in California history.

Settlement Secured
$10,000,000
Present value $7,835,000 · projected yield $10M+
15
Years litigated
40+
Court hearings
140+
IMR appeals
34+
Years, Thomas
Case Overview

What Happened to Michelle

An administrative worker suffered catastrophic injuries after slipping and falling down a staircase, severely damaging her lumbar spine and knees. Over many years, she required multiple lumbar and knee surgeries, ongoing rehabilitation, and eventually 24/7 home health care.

Despite the seriousness of her injuries and overwhelming medical documentation, the insurance carrier engaged in one of the most extreme denial and delay patterns Thomas DeBenedetto has encountered in more than 33 years of practice.

What followed was a 15-year legal battle that resulted in a present value settlement of $7,835,000 with a projected yield exceeding $10,000,000 one of the largest administrative worker catastrophic injury settlements ever recorded in California.

Michelle shares her experience after suffering a catastrophic fall down a staircase that required multiple surgeries and long-term home health care. Thomas DeBenedetto represented her for over 15 years and secured the $10 million settlement.

The Dispute

The Insurance Company Fought Every Step

From the beginning, the insurance company adopted a strategy of aggressive denial. This is the same pattern we see in denied workers' compensation claims across California but rarely to this extreme.

Persistent Denial and Delay of Medical Care

They refused or delayed essential:

  • Spinal surgeries
  • Knee surgeries
  • Specialist evaluations
  • Home health care
  • Pain management
  • Rehabilitative services
Over 140 Independent Medical Review appeals a rare and extraordinary number in California workers' compensation.

Unprecedented Litigation Resistance

The case required:

  • Over 40 court hearings the typical workers' comp case involves around 10.
  • Five penalty petitions, filed due to egregious conduct.
  • Multiple audits, triggered by systemic denial of care.
  • Direct contact with the Governor's office of California and the Administrative Director of the WCAB.

"I have never written the Governor or the Administrative Director regarding a claim. But the denial in this case was so egregious that I had no choice."

— Thomas DeBenedetto

The insurer's stance created devastating hardship for the injured worker and her family. Meanwhile, the defendant incurred over $4,000 per day to maintain two home health providers working 24/7, 365 days a year an expense they resisted acknowledging as medically necessary for years.

Legal Strategy

How Thomas Built the Case

To protect the worker's rights and overcome the insurer's resistance, Thomas developed a comprehensive and aggressive evidence-based strategy.

Medical and Surgical Evidence

  • Detailed reporting from orthopedic spine specialists
  • Knee reconstruction surgeons
  • Life-care planners
  • Neurologists and chronic pain experts
  • Functional capacity and vocational assessments

Permanent Disability Evaluation

The evidence conclusively showed the worker suffered permanent and total disability, complete loss of earning capacity, and lifelong reliance on home health assistance.

This case shows how strong evidence supports the highest levels of permanent disability benefits under California law.

Strategic Use of Litigation Pressure

40+ trial-level hearings, repeated sanctions, and penalty petitions compelled the insurer to comply with medical orders, escalated through audits and formal complaints.

This case shows how sustained litigation pressure forces accountability from a carrier that refuses to cooperate.

Exceptional Advocacy Measures

When traditional legal pathways failed due to the insurer's misconduct, Thomas wrote directly to Governor Gavin Newsom and corresponded with the Administrative Director of the WCAB an extraordinarily rare level of advocacy, undertaken only because the insurer's conduct severely endangered the worker's health and legal rights.

Michelle shares her experience after receiving a $10 million workers' compensation settlement for catastrophic workplace injuries
The Outcome

A $10 Million Settlement and Lifetime Care

Once confronted with overwhelming medical and legal evidence and mounting daily costs of home health care the defendant ultimately agreed to a $7.835M present value settlement, structured to yield over $10 million.

This settlement ensures:

Lifetime medical care

for all injury-related conditions

Financial security

for the worker and her family

Recognition of permanent disability
Closure and stability

after an extremely difficult injury and claims process

"This victory represents more than just a settlement figure. It demonstrates that persistence, strategy, and a willingness to challenge the highest levels of the system can overcome even the most entrenched obstacles."

— Thomas DeBenedetto
What This Means for You

What This Case Means for Other Injured Workers

Catastrophic injuries can happen in any workplace, including office environments.

Insurance carriers often underestimate or dispute the seriousness of administrative-worker injuries.

Persistent denials, IMR delays, and refusal of care are common in complex cases.

Lifelong disability cases require deep strategic knowledge and unrelenting advocacy.

With the right attorney, even the most aggressively contested claims can result in life-changing settlements.

If your claim is denied, delayed, or undervalued or if you're struggling to get essential medical treatment we can help.

You Do Not Have to Face the Insurance Company Alone

If you or a loved one suffered a serious work injury in an office, warehouse, hospital, or construction site the insurance company already has a strategy. If you go in without one, you risk losing benefits you're owed.

Put 34+ years and $1 billion recovered in your corner.

Free Case Review · No Fee Until We Win

No cost. No obligation. Just answers.